MS ISA is a commonly used proxy/firewall application that may only allow authenticated connections.
The current implementation of UPM supports only limited numbers of attributes. However, it is currently missing support for NTLM:
This attributes are already supported by our application such as Confluence. Other examples of attributes are:
Related to JSP-77162 on SAC
IT was fixed, but not usable: SAL doesn't support NTLM but uses the same system properties. So setting NTLM properties for PAC would make SAL stop working. We can't deliver it like this.
We don't have the environment to test this so I'm resolving this as "Won't Fix" - we can't officially support this.
Surely someone can pull down a trial version of MS ISA server or one of the other hundreds of NTLM based proxy servers and set this up?
Resolving as Won't Fix because an environment can't be setup seems a bit of a cop out.
First up: nice surname
When it comes to supporting a specific configuration, unfortunately there's a lot more to it than just a one-time download-and-check. We need to:
Set it up in our Continuous Integration infrastructure.
Configure tests to run for each product.
Monitor the builds and fix any breakages. We ran over 65000 builds last month, and someone needs to look at and respond to every red build.
Build infrastructure for support engineers to replicate customer issues.
Train support engineers to diagnose NTLM authN issues.
All of this takes time and energy. Instead, we've decided to spend that time on work that's applicable to a broader section of our 22000+ commercial customer base. For example, we're spending a lot of time to make it easier to discover useful plugins. We're also investing in stabilising our APIs, so plugins are less likely to break in the future. And we've put a lot of time and energy into making it easier to install and upgrade JIRA and Confluence.
It's our belief that that work is a better investment of our limited resources, as the results will benefit all customers. You'll see these changes start to appear with JIRA 4.4 and continue through the year.
Does that make sense?
Integration Product Manager.
Same to you on the surname
Yeh I get that you have limited resources. I'm guessing that we're the not only customers that need NTLM support in UPM? Any windows based corporate will have the issue.
Its just disappointing is all.