Atlassian Marketplace
  1. Atlassian Marketplace
  2. AMKT-3846

Deployable add-ons with a plugin key historically different to the AMKT add-on key can no longer be uploaded

    Details

    • Type: Bug Bug
    • Status: Closed
    • Priority: Major Major
    • Resolution: Not a bug
    • Affects Version/s: None
    • Fix Version/s: None
    • Component/s: None
    • Labels:
      None

      Description

      Reported by Matthew Jensen, while trying to upload a new version of the Confluence Roadmap Plugin.

      Upon trying to upload a new version of the plugin, he received a new validation error:

      Add-on key in plugin descriptor (com.atlassian.plugins.confluence-roadmap-plugin) did not match existing add-on (com.atlassian.confluence.plugins.confluence-roadmap-plugin)

      The plugin key in the jar had never changed. The problem was that when the marketplace listing was first created, the plugin key and add-on key were allowed to be different.

      It took us a little while to work out what the exact problem was, so this may be confusing for any external developers in the same situation.

      If this new validation really must exist, can we go through and identify anyone else who might be affected and either automatically change their add-on key for them, or I can contact them and let them know what to do?

      1. badjarobr
        13 kB
        Maleko Taylor
      2. notjarobr
        6 kB
        Maleko Taylor

        Activity

        Hide
        Joseph Clark added a comment -

        I haven't had time to dig in to this as the SPAC migrations are taking up all my time. Do you have time to own this, Maleko? Otherwise, I can look at it in about 3 weeks once the SPAC migrations for external vendors are done.

        Show
        Joseph Clark added a comment - I haven't had time to dig in to this as the SPAC migrations are taking up all my time. Do you have time to own this, Maleko? Otherwise, I can look at it in about 3 weeks once the SPAC migrations for external vendors are done.
        Hide
        Jozef Kotlár [EEA} added a comment -

        I would like to ask what is the state for this issue? We have this problem with uploading new version of add-on FEYWA. Thanks.

        Show
        Jozef Kotlár [EEA} added a comment - I would like to ask what is the state for this issue? We have this problem with uploading new version of add-on FEYWA . Thanks.
        Hide
        Joseph Clark added a comment -

        HI Jozef,

        This is still a problem - you have two choices:

        1) Rename your plugin's add-on key to match the unique key of your Marketplace add-on listing.

        2) We can change the unique key in the Marketplace add-on listing on the server side to match your add-on key.

        If you want us to change the key on the marketplace server, please email developer-relations@atlassian.com with your request and I'll sort it out.

        Show
        Joseph Clark added a comment - HI Jozef, This is still a problem - you have two choices: 1) Rename your plugin's add-on key to match the unique key of your Marketplace add-on listing. 2) We can change the unique key in the Marketplace add-on listing on the server side to match your add-on key. If you want us to change the key on the marketplace server, please email developer-relations@atlassian.com with your request and I'll sort it out.
        Hide
        Eric Dalgliesh added a comment -

        Eli Bishop, My current thoughts are that we should cut our losses in JIRA and bundle the new version of the plugin with a different key than what we currently bundle. This will make the MPAC update start working again on later versions of JIRA. So please *don't * change the plugin key at this stage

        Show
        Eric Dalgliesh added a comment - Eli Bishop , My current thoughts are that we should cut our losses in JIRA and bundle the new version of the plugin with a different key than what we currently bundle. This will make the MPAC update start working again on later versions of JIRA. So please *don't * change the plugin key at this stage
        Hide
        Eli Bishop added a comment -

        Eric Dalgliesh Three different plugins have been mentioned on this issue, so could you please clarify which one you don't want us to change?

        Show
        Eli Bishop added a comment - Eric Dalgliesh Three different plugins have been mentioned on this issue, so could you please clarify which one you don't want us to change?

          People

          • Assignee:
            Unassigned
            Reporter:
            Joseph Clark
          • Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            12 Start watching this issue

            Dates

            • Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved:

              Who's Looking?